Letter of 7 October 1987 from Lillian Caplin of the Center for Musical Antiquities, New York, to G. E. Valley Jr.: she sends pre-Civil War price lists, has never seen an advertisement by Edward Baack, has sold one Baack flute and has another, and names Fred Oster as the man who auctioned the Selch Baack clarinet. With Valley's replies of 12 October 1987 to her and to Oster.
History · 7 Oct 1987 · New York, New York, United States
Linked to Heinrich Eduard Baack, Sr. and George Edward Valley Jr
[Notebook p. 26, headed "BAACK", date stamp OCT 12 1987: typed letter pasted in. GEV's notes: "I wrote to Oster on 4 Jun 87, no answer, VLCMK7" [date as written]; "See pp 44-45 for the stuff she enclosed". The phone numbers in the letter are left out.] Lillian Caplin, The Center for Musical Antiquities, 544 East 86 Street, New York City, New York 10028 October 7, 1987 George E. Valley Jr. 607 Main Street Concord Massachusetts 01742 Dear Mr. Valley, I hope that the enclosed material will prove useful to you in your research project. The price lists precede the Civil War somewhat, but I have not been able to put my hand on pricelists issued during the Civil War. Descriptive catalogues are not easily available before the mid 1870's. Keep in touch and if further information turns up I'll be happy to share it with you. I can't recall seeing ads for Edward Baack's instruments. If you can check business directories for the years he was in business there are usually advertisements interspersed in the volumes and perhaps he placed some himself. Also in old musical journals and periodicals....they are excellent sources for current ads. Fred Oster was in charge of the Christie's auction that included the sale of Erich Selch's Baack clarinet. His address is: Fred Oster, Vintage Instruments, 1529 Pine Street, Philadelphia, Pa. 19102. He should be able to identify the current owner. We sold a one-keyed Baack flute about seven years ago. It was a fine playing boxwood and ivory example. We have another one-keyed Baack flute currently in our possession. Unfortunately we have not come across any of his clarinets. You might want to run a small ad in the AMIS Newsletter for further information. I would appreciate any information on your great-grandfather that you will share with us. Sincerely, [signed] Lillian Caplin
[Notebook p. 27, headed "BAACK": GEV's typed reply pasted in. The phone number is left out.] GEORGE E. VALLEY, JR. 607 MAIN STREET CONCORD MA 01742 October 12, 1987 Ms. Lillian Caplin The Center For Musical Antiquities 544 East 86 Street New York New York 10028 Dear Ms. Caplin: Thank you for your very informative letter of October 7, 1987. I am enclosing an annotated list of dates about the life of Edward Baack. I hope the information that Fred Oster sold the Selch Baack clarinet will help me to locate it. I wrote Mr. Oster on June 4, 1987, asking about Baack instruments, but he didn't answer me, and so I have little hope that he will answer my second letter either. For your amusement, I enclose copies of both my letters to Mr. Oster. If you do happen to hear of a Baack clarinet, particularly one that is in condition to be played, I think that I have a customer for it. Meanwhile, I think that your suggestion of placing an ad in the AMIS newsletter is a good one. Thank you again for your help. Sincerely yours, [signed] G E Valley George E. Valley, Jr. 1.Printed on October 12, 1987, File VLCMN2 [GEV: Sent her copies of: VLCM M9, VLCM N3, VLCM K7]
[Notebook p. 28, headed "BAACK": GEV's typed letter pasted in. The phone number is left out.] GEORGE E. VALLEY, JR. 607 MAIN STREET CONCORD MA 01742 October 12, 1987 Mr. Fred Oster VINTAGE INSTRUMENTS 1529 Pine Street Philadelphia PA 19102 Dear Mr. Oster: Lillian Caplin informs me that you were in charge of the Christie's auction that included the sale of Mr. Selch's Baack clarinet. I am trying to track that clarinet down, in order to obtain a photo of it for my biographical paper about Edward Baack, which is nearly finished. If your records show who bought the Baack clarinet, please let me know the buyer's name and address. If it would be of interest to you, I can give you some information about the career of Edward Baack. Thank you for any help that you are able to give me. Sincerely yours, [signed] G E Valley George E. Valley, Jr. Professor of Physics, Emeritus Massachusetts Institute of Technology cc Lillian Caplin 1.Printed on October 12, 1987, File VLCMN3
Notes
Source: Lillian Caplin, Center for Musical Antiquities, letter to G. E. Valley Jr., 7 Oct 1987, with his replies to her and to Fred Oster, 12 Oct 1987 Location: G. E. Valley Jr.'s research notebook VLCM #5 (begun 14 Sep 1987), part 2, pp. 26-28; Valley family papers, storage bin Found by: Claude research assistant


