G. E. Valley Jr.'s notes of 22-25 March 1988 listing the computer files he built from the tax lists, and his analysis of Edward Baack's assessed valuation as a wholesale dealer at 87 Fulton Street ($33,372 in 1865, $39,724 in 1866) against other dealers in the same division, concluding that Baack's valuation grew less than most and that he may have been losing money in constant dollars; with a printout of his sorting plan.
History · 25 Mar 1988 · Concord, Middlesex, Massachusetts, United States
Linked to Heinrich Eduard Baack, Sr. and George Edward Valley Jr
6 pages. Open one to read it full size.
[Notebook p. 88, date stamp MAR 22 1988: GEV's list of his computer files of the tax lists.] Here are the current tax files: 1) MAR65ALL.SRT - Sorted monthly list for March 1865 2) Month Aug.63B - unsorted monthly list August 1863 for B's only 3) Month S4V.ALL - unsorted monthly lists (includes the two above) 4) MonMar65ALL - the unsorted source for (1) above 5) Month Nov.62B - like (2) above but for Nov 1862 6) VLCML7US.MON - unsorted B's for Aug 63 & Nov 62 7) VLCMTAXF.ORM - Heading & footnotes for sorted annual list. 8) VLCML7YR.TAX - Sorted & headed annual list for 63 & 64 9) VLCML7SR.TED - Same as 8 but without heads so it can be resorted etc. [10) VLCML7UN.SRT - original unsorted version of (9), crossed out] 11) VLCML7-1.863 - 1863/1 & 1863/2 unsorted (3/1 sorted) [12) and 13) crossed out] 12) VLCML763.SRT - this is (11) sorted 13) MONMAR66.ALL - unsorted monthly list for Mar 1866 14) MAR66ALL.SRT - sorted version of (13) above 15) MAR65&66.SRT - combines (14) & (1)
[Notebook p. 89: the file list continued.] 16 VLCML7MO.YRS is a sorted combination of MAR65&66.SRT plus VLCML7YR.TAX 17 VLCML7BA.ACK is an extract of (16) showing BAACK's neighbors on odd side of street 18 VLCM4YRS.TAX is an unsorted list of 1863/1, 3/2, 64, 65, 66 assessment for the A's & B's of Ward 2 (not just for Fulton Street) The sort for this one is a,1,2; m,1,1; n,3,1. It sorts first on street name, then on street number, then on year. Should sort on Street, number, name, year: a13, n11, a21, n31. OK (only one Tab between fields). Numbers are 3 digits + space, streets are 7 digits TAB; only one Tab before occupations. [number 4 spaces, street 7 spaces, Tab, Name 11, Tab, date 6, TAB] 19) VLCMSRT4.YRS is sorted version of 18: a12, n11, a21, n31. In order to sort the data, the names must be consistently spelled
[Notebook p. 90, date stamps MAR 24 1988 and MAR 25 1988.] The sort by occupation of VLCM4YRS.TAX is a41, a12, n11, a21, n31. This is File VLCMSRT4.OCC [25 Mar 1988] Edward Baack's 1866 Assessment: 39,724; 1865: 33,372. Ratio 66/65 = 1.19 Did his assessment increase more, or less, than average? Here are other values, taken from VLCMSRT4.YRS: Baeler [?] Delany & Adamson 642,272 and 586,000 Adams J J Co (50,000 30,000) omit too even Blodgett Brown & Co 276,496 185,200 Am. Hard Rubber Co 399,013 223,600 Boker Hermann & Co (1,000,000 447,942) omit this Beam & Murray (491,055 191,181 ?) omit ? Bach & Nostrand (50,000 48,595) omit too even Bynner & Boyce (300,000 110,800) omit too even Bussing Abm, Agt (170,000 105,100) omit too even all figures except ? etc: 2,887,781 1,737,237 ratio 1.66 The three most detailed sets of figures: 642,272 586,000; 276,496 185,200; 399,013 223,600; total 1,317,781 994,800. Ratio = 1.32
[Notebook p. 91, date stamp MAR 25 1988.] If Edward Baack's valuation for 1865 had increased by 1.32, his 1866 valuation would have been 44,051 or 4327 larger than it was, i.e. about 10%. If E B's valuation for 1865 had been increased by 1.66, then his 1866 valuation would have been 55,397, a gain of 15,674. But the gains of Boker Hermann & Bynner & Boyce seem unusual & cannot be ascribed to a general inflation. .'. 1.19 is the most conservative ratio; 1.66 is the improbably large ratio. Perhaps if all, but Boker Hermann, Bynner & Boyce & the suspect values for Beam & Murray, are totaled we get a median ratio: 642272 586,000 1.10; 50 000 30,000 1.67; 276 496 185,200 1.49; 399 013 223,600 1.78; 50 000 48 595 1.03; [300 000 110 800 2.70 struck out]; 170 000 105 100 1.62. Mean = 1.24. Total 1,587,781 1,178,495 ratio 1.35 The fairest analysis is to present the individual ratios
[Notebook p. 92, date stamp MAR 25 1988.] Name, Valuation 1865, Value 1866, Ratio Baeder [?] Delany & Adamson 586,000 642,272 1.10 Adams J J & Co 30,000 50,000 1.67 * Blodgett Brown & Co 185 200 276,496 1.49 Am. Hard Rubber Co 223 600 399 013 1.78 Boker Hermann & Co 447942 1,000,000 2.23 * Bach & Nostrand 48595 50,000 1.03 * Bynner & Boyce 110,800 300,000 2.71 * Baack Edward 33,372 39,724 1.19 Bussing Abm, Agt 105,100 170,000 1.62 This shows Edward Baack having a ratio in increase that is third lowest & 6th from the top. If the ratios of Boker Hermann & Bynner & Boyce are omitted as being too high to be accounted for by inflation alone, and if those of Adams, & Bach & Nostrand are omitted as being probably inaccurate round numbers, then Baack is 2nd from bottom & third from top. || The conclusion is that Edward Baack's valuation increased less than the mean ratios for other shop keepers. He may therefore have been losing money in constant dollars.
[Notebook p. 93, date stamps MAR 25 1988: GEV's plan for sorting his computer file of the monthly tax lists, with a pasted printout "The Monthly Tax Lists for the Civil War: Test and Plan of Sorting" showing sample lines (Grannis Theo. C., 41 Fulton, shirts, collars &c.; Stackpole & Bro., 41 Ann, nautical instruments; DeBarry & G., 43 William, stencil materials; Burtnett Wm. B., 45 Beekman, brushes; Bayer F. W. and Mayer F. W., Cliff Street, paper boxes).] The sort for the monthly records is a21, a12, n11, a13, n15, n14 or: occupation, street, number, name, year, month. The format is number 3, space 1, street 7, space 1, name 19, space 1, month 2 ... It is not practical to have > 75 spaces on the monitor screen. .'. 10, 85 are biggest margins that can be handled. [Printout:] The sort is by occupation, street, number, name, year, month. The format is: number3, sp1, street7, sp1, name19, sp1, mo2, sp1, yr2, tab5, occupation19, sp1, income7, sp1, tax-rate2, tab, tab. [GEV: use 8, 83 to make tab lie on 5%.] It is not possible to have more than 75 characters on a monitor line, so that the margin set 10,85 is about the best that can be done.
Notes
Source: G. E. Valley Jr., notes on his tax-list files and analysis of Edward Baack's 1865-1866 valuations, 22-25 Mar 1988 (notebook VLCM #5, pp. 88-93) Location: G. E. Valley Jr.'s research notebook VLCM #5 (begun 14 Sep 1987), part 3, pp. 88-93; Valley family papers, storage bin Found by: Claude research assistant





