← Media

G. E. Valley Jr.'s notes of 22-25 March 1988 listing the computer files he built from the tax lists, and his analysis of Edward Baack's assessed valuation as a wholesale dealer at 87 Fulton Street ($33,372 in 1865, $39,724 in 1866) against other dealers in the same division, concluding that Baack's valuation grew less than most and that he may have been losing money in constant dollars; with a printout of his sorting plan.

History · 25 Mar 1988 · Concord, Middlesex, Massachusetts, United States

Linked to Heinrich Eduard Baack, Sr. and George Edward Valley Jr

6 pages. Open one to read it full size.

  1. Notebook p. 88

    Notebook p. 88

  2. Notebook p. 89

    Notebook p. 89

  3. Notebook p. 90

    Notebook p. 90

  4. Notebook p. 91

    Notebook p. 91

  5. Notebook p. 92

    Notebook p. 92

  6. Notebook p. 93

    Notebook p. 93

[Notebook p. 88, date stamp MAR 22 1988: GEV's list of his computer files of the tax lists.] Here are the current tax files: 1) MAR65ALL.SRT - Sorted monthly list for March 1865 2) Month Aug.63B - unsorted monthly list August 1863 for B's only 3) Month S4V.ALL - unsorted monthly lists (includes the two above) 4) MonMar65ALL - the unsorted source for (1) above 5) Month Nov.62B - like (2) above but for Nov 1862 6) VLCML7US.MON - unsorted B's for Aug 63 & Nov 62 7) VLCMTAXF.ORM - Heading & footnotes for sorted annual list. 8) VLCML7YR.TAX - Sorted & headed annual list for 63 & 64 9) VLCML7SR.TED - Same as 8 but without heads so it can be resorted etc. [10) VLCML7UN.SRT - original unsorted version of (9), crossed out] 11) VLCML7-1.863 - 1863/1 & 1863/2 unsorted (3/1 sorted) [12) and 13) crossed out] 12) VLCML763.SRT - this is (11) sorted 13) MONMAR66.ALL - unsorted monthly list for Mar 1866 14) MAR66ALL.SRT - sorted version of (13) above 15) MAR65&66.SRT - combines (14) & (1)

[Notebook p. 89: the file list continued.] 16 VLCML7MO.YRS is a sorted combination of MAR65&66.SRT plus VLCML7YR.TAX 17 VLCML7BA.ACK is an extract of (16) showing BAACK's neighbors on odd side of street 18 VLCM4YRS.TAX is an unsorted list of 1863/1, 3/2, 64, 65, 66 assessment for the A's & B's of Ward 2 (not just for Fulton Street) The sort for this one is a,1,2; m,1,1; n,3,1. It sorts first on street name, then on street number, then on year. Should sort on Street, number, name, year: a13, n11, a21, n31. OK (only one Tab between fields). Numbers are 3 digits + space, streets are 7 digits TAB; only one Tab before occupations. [number 4 spaces, street 7 spaces, Tab, Name 11, Tab, date 6, TAB] 19) VLCMSRT4.YRS is sorted version of 18: a12, n11, a21, n31. In order to sort the data, the names must be consistently spelled

[Notebook p. 90, date stamps MAR 24 1988 and MAR 25 1988.] The sort by occupation of VLCM4YRS.TAX is a41, a12, n11, a21, n31. This is File VLCMSRT4.OCC [25 Mar 1988] Edward Baack's 1866 Assessment: 39,724; 1865: 33,372. Ratio 66/65 = 1.19 Did his assessment increase more, or less, than average? Here are other values, taken from VLCMSRT4.YRS: Baeler [?] Delany & Adamson 642,272 and 586,000 Adams J J Co (50,000 30,000) omit too even Blodgett Brown & Co 276,496 185,200 Am. Hard Rubber Co 399,013 223,600 Boker Hermann & Co (1,000,000 447,942) omit this Beam & Murray (491,055 191,181 ?) omit ? Bach & Nostrand (50,000 48,595) omit too even Bynner & Boyce (300,000 110,800) omit too even Bussing Abm, Agt (170,000 105,100) omit too even all figures except ? etc: 2,887,781 1,737,237 ratio 1.66 The three most detailed sets of figures: 642,272 586,000; 276,496 185,200; 399,013 223,600; total 1,317,781 994,800. Ratio = 1.32

[Notebook p. 91, date stamp MAR 25 1988.] If Edward Baack's valuation for 1865 had increased by 1.32, his 1866 valuation would have been 44,051 or 4327 larger than it was, i.e. about 10%. If E B's valuation for 1865 had been increased by 1.66, then his 1866 valuation would have been 55,397, a gain of 15,674. But the gains of Boker Hermann & Bynner & Boyce seem unusual & cannot be ascribed to a general inflation. .'. 1.19 is the most conservative ratio; 1.66 is the improbably large ratio. Perhaps if all, but Boker Hermann, Bynner & Boyce & the suspect values for Beam & Murray, are totaled we get a median ratio: 642272 586,000 1.10; 50 000 30,000 1.67; 276 496 185,200 1.49; 399 013 223,600 1.78; 50 000 48 595 1.03; [300 000 110 800 2.70 struck out]; 170 000 105 100 1.62. Mean = 1.24. Total 1,587,781 1,178,495 ratio 1.35 The fairest analysis is to present the individual ratios

[Notebook p. 92, date stamp MAR 25 1988.] Name, Valuation 1865, Value 1866, Ratio Baeder [?] Delany & Adamson 586,000 642,272 1.10 Adams J J & Co 30,000 50,000 1.67 * Blodgett Brown & Co 185 200 276,496 1.49 Am. Hard Rubber Co 223 600 399 013 1.78 Boker Hermann & Co 447942 1,000,000 2.23 * Bach & Nostrand 48595 50,000 1.03 * Bynner & Boyce 110,800 300,000 2.71 * Baack Edward 33,372 39,724 1.19 Bussing Abm, Agt 105,100 170,000 1.62 This shows Edward Baack having a ratio in increase that is third lowest & 6th from the top. If the ratios of Boker Hermann & Bynner & Boyce are omitted as being too high to be accounted for by inflation alone, and if those of Adams, & Bach & Nostrand are omitted as being probably inaccurate round numbers, then Baack is 2nd from bottom & third from top. || The conclusion is that Edward Baack's valuation increased less than the mean ratios for other shop keepers. He may therefore have been losing money in constant dollars.

[Notebook p. 93, date stamps MAR 25 1988: GEV's plan for sorting his computer file of the monthly tax lists, with a pasted printout "The Monthly Tax Lists for the Civil War: Test and Plan of Sorting" showing sample lines (Grannis Theo. C., 41 Fulton, shirts, collars &c.; Stackpole & Bro., 41 Ann, nautical instruments; DeBarry & G., 43 William, stencil materials; Burtnett Wm. B., 45 Beekman, brushes; Bayer F. W. and Mayer F. W., Cliff Street, paper boxes).] The sort for the monthly records is a21, a12, n11, a13, n15, n14 or: occupation, street, number, name, year, month. The format is number 3, space 1, street 7, space 1, name 19, space 1, month 2 ... It is not practical to have > 75 spaces on the monitor screen. .'. 10, 85 are biggest margins that can be handled. [Printout:] The sort is by occupation, street, number, name, year, month. The format is: number3, sp1, street7, sp1, name19, sp1, mo2, sp1, yr2, tab5, occupation19, sp1, income7, sp1, tax-rate2, tab, tab. [GEV: use 8, 83 to make tab lie on 5%.] It is not possible to have more than 75 characters on a monitor line, so that the margin set 10,85 is about the best that can be done.

Notes

Source: G. E. Valley Jr., notes on his tax-list files and analysis of Edward Baack's 1865-1866 valuations, 22-25 Mar 1988 (notebook VLCM #5, pp. 88-93) Location: G. E. Valley Jr.'s research notebook VLCM #5 (begun 14 Sep 1987), part 3, pp. 88-93; Valley family papers, storage bin Found by: Claude research assistant