← Media

Letter from Professor Harold Hancock (March 1987) reporting that he found Martha Rebecca Ringgold's death certificate in Dover, and on the progress of the Cummins family manuscript with Mrs. Megson; G. E. Valley Jr.'s reply (April 1987) on Martha's children, John Ringgold Cummins and the Belton name; and GEV's notes of a call learning that Hancock had died on 9 July 1987. A sentence about Hancock's health is left out; the notes page is partly out of focus.

History · Mar-Aug 1987 · Westerville, Franklin, Ohio, United States

Linked to George Wilson Cummins, Frances Blackiston Cummins, John Ringgold Cummins, Martha Rebecca Cummins, William Charles Clayton Ringgold, Rebecca B Ringgold, Frances Wingate Davis, John Holliday Cummins, Jean Marion Swanson and George Edward Valley Jr

4 pages. Open one to read it full size.

  1. Notebook p. 196

    Notebook p. 196

  2. Notebook p. 198

    Notebook p. 198

  3. Notebook p. 199

    Notebook p. 199

  4. Notebook p. 224

    Notebook p. 224

[Notebook p. 196. Typed letter from Professor Harold Hancock to GEV, pasted in. GEV's note: "rec'd 26 Mar 87".] 111 West Park St. Westerville, Ohio 43081 March 24, 1987

Dear Dr. Valley:

[An opening sentence about the writer's health is left out of this transcription.]

I thought that you would be interested in the progress we are making on the manuscript. We have finished everything and are now working on revisions and modifications. I told Mrs. Megson, Mrs. Cummins' daughter, that I thought we should go over the whole thing. Just yesterday I sent her my response to certain revisions along with maps of Smyrna and Duck Creek Hundred in 1868 and the Noxon map of Dover of 1740 as revised by Thomas Rodney.

Last week I flew to Philadelphia and then on by shuttle bus to Wilmington to work on a manuscript I am doing on Delaware 200 Years Ago for the Bicentennial of the Constitution. In Dover I went to the Bureau of Vital Statistics to check on Rebecca Cummins. Guess what? There was nothing under that name, but under Martha Rebecca Ringgold there was filed her death certificate signed by her son, a copy of which I enclose.

I sent Mrs. Megson a trial index of the first 25 pages, and she thought we should restrict the number of names--not to include the people mentioned as living in surrounding farms in deeds. I disagree with this, believing that genealogists would want to know if any of their ancestors were included in such places.

She also referred vaguely in one letter to the fact that she would begin to check on publishers or printers, but so far has done nothing about it.

I believe that at the progress we are making it will be at least a year before the manuscript goes to press, but I am sure that it will.

I am very appreciative of your assistance with the descendants of John Holliday Cummins.

Sincerely yours, [signed] Harold Hancock

[Notebook p. 198. Copy of GEV's typed letter to Professor Harold Hancock, page 1, pasted in.] GEORGE E. VALLEY, JR. 607 MAIN STREET CONCORD MA 01742 617 369 5692

April 21, 1987

Dr. Harold Hancock 111 West Park Street Westerville Ohio 43081

Dear Dr. Hancock:

I found your letter when I returned from my problems and duties. The news that you'd been having a rough time is distressing, but I'm cheered by your recovery. When I was told I had angina, about 15 years ago, I decided to work for and to enjoy myself, and as soon as I could I retired. As a result, the angina seems not to have worsened.

But it's wonderful news that you are still active in the Cummins cause. When I didn't hear from you, I concluded that you'd finally had it with your patroness and given up.

Of course I agree with you about the inclusion of neighboring families. For instance where is the farm of Walter Speakman, whose family was so intimate with the Cummins's, and who told me such a yarn about George W. Cummins in his dotage? As you note, family histories are primarily of interest to historians and genealogists, people who may be concerned with topics you and I (and Mrs. Megson) can't imagine. Those researchers will bless you for including as much auxiliary material as possible.

Hooray for your having located Martha Rebecca's death certificate. I can now finish my paper about John H. Cummins and his family. Rebecca took her children to Smyrna when she found that her share of Clayton Ringgolds estate wasn't much, and that as the fourth wife she had a lot of non-filial stepsons to contend with. They also seem to have been prize dolts.

Now if we could locate the elder son, John Ringgold Cummins, we'd know about the lot of them. I have not been able to locate John R. Cummins, nor do I know where John Holliday Cummins and his wife Rebecca B. (Ringgold) Cummins are buried. Not in Delaware according to the state, and not in Baltimore city. Probably someplace in greater Baltimore, but those records are not easily located.

[Notebook p. 199. Page 2 of the letter to Hancock.] Harold Hancock 2 G.E.VALLEY

There is also the unverified identity of my cousin Clarence Ringgold Cummins who visited my parents during the depression, in order to put the touch on them. I suspect that Clarence Cummins must have been the son of John Ringgold Cummins, but only on the basis that the Cavender papers mention John Ringgold Cummins as being still alive and fail to mention Clarence--consistent with his being a child of John Ringgold Cummins.

I have a fairly detailed account of the last years of Clarence Ringgold Cummins from my sister in law, Jean Valley, and I'll send you a copy of it if you're interested.

In a few weeks I shall have a draft of my final Cummins paper completed, and I'd like to send it to you for your criticism and correction.

By the way, doesn't it seem likely that Rebecca B. Ringgold was named after her mother, who was born a Belton: Rebecca Belton Ringgold? Belton seems more probable to me than Brown, and much more probable than Brackiston.

Sincerely, [signed] George George E. Valley, Jr. [handwritten:] VLCMJ9

[Notebook p. 224. GEV's notes of telephone calls, about August 1987. The page was photographed out of focus; the top half can't be read in full. Phone numbers and a private home address are left out.] [Top half, fragments:] ... Hancock's house ... Westerville, Ohio 43081 ... [someone] answered - ... [he died] July 9! ... [the] Cummins papers ... other papers ... Elizabeth Hancock ... [had] never heard of Mrs Megson ... Called Elizabeth Hancock MISS, 3205 Falcon Lane #217, Wilmington Delaware 19808 He died in her house; he had finished the Cummins book & it [is] to be printed by Mrs Megson. All his papers [went] to the Delaware Historical Society which has permission to destroy duplicates. Mrs Megson was at Funeral. Mrs Harry K Megson, Hebron Conn 06248 [last line partly cut off:] ... Fri night

Notes

Source: Letters, Harold Hancock and G. E. Valley Jr., Mar-Apr 1987, with GEV's notes of Hancock's death (notebook VLCM 4, pp. 196, 198-199, 224) Location: G. E. Valley Jr.'s research notebook VLCM #4 (1 Jul 1986 - 14 Sep 1987), part 3, pp. 196, 198, 199, 224; Valley family papers, storage bin Found by: Claude research assistant