Letters between G. E. Valley Jr. and instrument dealers and collectors in his search for Edward Baack's instruments, October-December 1986: Bram A. Bury, David Shorey, Stuart Caplin of the Center for Musical Antiquities (with Polaroids of its boxwood Baack flute, offered at $450) and Sid Glickman.
History · Oct-Dec 1986 · Concord, Middlesex, Massachusetts, United States
Linked to Heinrich Eduard Baack, Sr. and George Edward Valley Jr
7 pages. Open one to read it full size.
[Notebook p. 152. Copies of two near-identical typed letters from GEV, dated "October 32, 1986", pasted side by side: to Mr. Bram A. Bury, 184 North Franklin Street, Holbrook MA 02343, and to Mr. David Shorey, P. O. Box 92, Bowdoinham ME 04008.] Dear Mr. Bury:
Lloyd Farrar has given me your name as one who may own or have knowledge of instruments made by Edward Baack (fl. 1837-1873). I need photographs and valuations of Baack instruments for a definitive account of his life. I possess most of the relevant documents other than pictures of his work, as the enclosed copy of one of his bills may testify.
If you have a Baack instrument, I will gladly pay the cost of photographing it so that the Baack imprint appears in the picture.
I hope that you will be able to help me. I enclose a self-addressed envelope for your convenience.
Thank you again for taking the time to read and consider this letter.
Sincerely yours, [signed] George E. Valley, Jr., Professor of Physics, Emeritus, Massachusetts Institute of Technology [The letter to Mr. Shorey is worded the same.]
[Notebook p. 153. The letter to David Shorey. See p. 152.]
[Notebook p. 155. A postcard from Bramwell A. Bury of Holbrook, Mass. (the printed side advertises Florida rental apartments), and a Post Office delivery notice, pasted in. Date stamps NOV 12 1986.] November 8, 1986 Dear Dr. Valley: I never heard of a Baack instrument. I sent your inquiry on to Mr. Sidney Glickman of 53 Leighton Avenue, Yonkers, New York 10705. He may have some information for you or know of someone who does, in New York or New Jersey. [signed] B. A. Bury
[Post Office "Delivery Notice or Receipt", PS Form 3849, for an express-mail flat addressed to George Valley, 607 Main St., 11-12 (1986).] [GEV's note:] Postoffice says this is from Baltimore
[Notebook p. 156. Typed letter from Stuart Caplin of The Center for Musical Antiquities, New York, to GEV, pasted in. GEV's notes: "see p 151"; "Baach"; "rec'd 14 Nov 86".] Lillian Caplin, The Center for Musical Antiquities, 544 East 86 Street, New York City, New York 10028
Nov. 11, 1986
George E. Valley Jr. 607 Main Street Concord, MA 01742
Dear Mr. Valley:
Referring to your letter regarding our Baack flute, we can give you the following description.
Key of F sounding length 43 cm. Boxwood with ivory mounts, 1 square brass key. Each joint is stamped E. BAACK / N. YORK
The flute is in very fine condition. There is a finely repaired crack on the head joint that does not affect the embouchoure. The mount at the foot joint has a crack, and the end pin is missing.
Unfortunately, we don't know of a photographer who can take the pictures you need. As you know, the lettering is quite faint. Maybe you have some ideas on solving this problem. Our experiences with professional photographers has not been satisfactory and we rely on Polaroids.
The price of the flute is $450.00.
We apologize for not answering all your questions but feel that the problem can be worked out, especially if your friend is anxious to purchase this instrument.
Sincerely, [signed] Stuart Caplin
[Notebook p. 157. Copy of GEV's typed reply to Stuart Caplin, pasted in. GEV's notes: "Baach"; "see p 166".] GEORGE E. VALLEY, JR. 607 MAIN STREET, CONCORD, MA 01742 617 369 5692
November 20, 1986
Mr. Stuart Caplin The Center For Musical Antiquities 544 East 86 Street New York New York 10028
Dear Mr. Caplin:
Thank you for your informative letter describing the Baack flute that you have for sale. While I cannot tell you that my friend in Los Angeles is definitely interested in this instrument, I can say with some assurance that he would want to see a photograph of it before traveling all the way to New York to inspect it.
I think we would both be satisfied with polaroid photos, assuming that the instrument is photographed from reasonably close and against a suitably tinted back cloth--things that any experienced amateur might attend to. I share your skepticism of professional photographers for such purposes. The only reliable ones that I have ever met were in the employ of large organizations: museums, universities, and companies the like of ATT, UTC etc. It is much better to learn to make pretty good pictures oneself than to rely on the fellow down the street; he will charge excessively and produce work all too often that looks like a 12 year old had done it in in his mother's pantry.
Please oblige me by a polaroid or two of the Baack flute, and I will reimburse you for it, and give you ample credit if I circulate any copies.
My friend, who is an experienced clarinetist, would be interested if you should run across a Baack clarinet, even if it were not in playable condition.
Sincerely yours, [signed] G. E. Valley George E. Valley, Jr. Professor of Physics, Emeritus Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Printed on November 20, 1986, FILE VLCMJ6
[Notebook p. 166. Photocopies of two Polaroid photographs of the Baack flute, and the second letter from Stuart Caplin of The Center for Musical Antiquities (undated, received about December 1986), pasted in.] [Under the photographs, Caplin's note:] SIGNED ON EACH JOINT
We are enclosing 2 polaroids of our Baack flute. There will be no charge.
If your friend is interested in purchasing this flute, there is no need for him to make a special trip. We will refund any payment if the instrument is returned after being held for a week. Incidentally, the only time that this happened with us occured when a gentleman ordered a Giorgi flute on the condition that he could play it. Apparantly he couldn't so we refunded the money as soon as we received the flute back.
We hope that we have been of help to you. As far as the clarinet is concerned, we have never seen one but will be on the look out. In this business, one never knows what can show up.
Sincerely, [signed] Stuart Caplin
[Notebook p. 167. Handwritten note from Sid Glickman, Musical Instruments, Irvington-on-Hudson, N.Y., on his printed letterhead, pasted in, with B. A. Bury's return-address label.] 12-1-86 Dear Prof. Valley, At the present time I do not own any instruments by "Baack", but I shall be glad to inform you if any turn up. Please be aware that I am actively collecting in case any interesting instruments cross your path. Sincerely [signed] Sid Glickman [GEV's note, circled:] This arrived in my return envelope sent to Mr Bury, with his return address on it.
Notes
Source: Letters between G. E. Valley Jr. and dealers and collectors about Edward Baack's instruments, Oct-Dec 1986 (notebook VLCM 4) Location: G. E. Valley Jr.'s research notebook VLCM #4 (1 Jul 1986 - 14 Sep 1987), part 2, pp. 152, 153, 155, 156, 157, 166, 167; Valley family papers, storage bin Found by: Claude research assistant






